Is bitcoin's incorruptibility at risk with institutional influence?
07/26/2024 01:47The debate over BlackRock's bitcoin involvement highlights the tension between mass adoption and centralization risks.
Bitcoin's path from a niche digital asset to a mainstream investment has stirred debates about its future in the hands of major financial institutions. This discussion, led by Roundtable anchor Rob Nelson, and Noah Newton, CEO of Moby Media, brings into focus the delicate balance between mass adoption and centralization.
Nelson initiated the conversation by pondering the dual nature of ETF adoption. He acknowledged the importance of mass adoption facilitated by ETFs but expressed concern about the concentration of bitcoin in the hands of major financial institutions like BlackRock. This concern touches on the original ethos of bitcoin, which aimed to decentralize control away from such entities.
Noah Newton responded by emphasizing that bitcoin's journey into the hands of entities like BlackRock was inevitable. He explained, "Money typically concentrates towards the top of the hierarchy once people understand the value proposition of something like bitcoin." Newton argued that the influx of big money into bitcoin isn't necessarily bad, especially for those looking for price appreciation.
Newton pointed out that during significant price surges, not only bitcoin but also mid-caps, large caps, and small caps benefit immensely. However, he acknowledged the complexity of the situation, stating, "I honestly don't have enough information to confidently say if it's good to have so much bitcoin concentrated in the hands of an entity like BlackRock."
The financial giant only needed a few months to cement the lead its iShares Bitcoin Trust now has in the Bitcoin ETF race. At more than $22 billion in assets under management, BlackRock's Bitcoin ETF is now the largest and continues to outpace peers.
Rob Nelson highlighted bitcoin's unique nature. He argued that bitcoin remains somewhat incorruptible, even if large entities like BlackRock accumulate significant amounts. "Larry Fink, the CEO of BlackRock, may think he can control the market, but nobody's going to control bitcoin, even if you own a lot of it," Nelson remarked.
Noah Newton further elaborated on bitcoin's resilience, noting that despite the concentration of bitcoin in relatively few wallets even before BlackRock's involvement, the bitcoin network has never been compromised. He remained optimistic about bitcoin's future, expressing his unwavering commitment to holding bitcoin regardless of the involvement of big corporations or governments.